Sunday, 13 September 2015

A Vindication of the Rights of Women by Mary Wollestonecraft

Published: 1792

Mary Wollestonecraft was one of the historical heroines of"Second Wave" feminism, identified as "the first feminist", and her defining book A Vindication of the Rights of Women lauded as "the first" published work of feminist writing.  The "firsts" weren't true, of course, but in the early days of academic feminism the claims drew a lot of attention to Wollestonecraft.  Wollestonecraft was certainly an early feminist in the Western tradition, and was unique in her era as a woman who supported herself by her writing.  She was also the mother of Mary Wollestonecraft Shelley, author of Frankenstein, and Wollestonecrafts' own works presage Romanticism.

As you might imagine, Wollestonecraft has been the subject of many biographies.

I'm no longer sure why she initially drew my attention, but at this point I've read something like four of those biographies.  Wollestonecraft was a fascinating -- and difficult -- person.  No surprise.  The ordinary, less-stubborn, and more practical middle-class woman of the late eighteenth century became wives.  Failing marriage, they became dependents of their married siblings, or perhaps governesses or paid companions.   The truly unfortunate presumably became prostitutes and/or died in penury.  All of those fates were intolerable to Wollestonecraft.  Some combination of determination and luck allowed her to transcend her failed career as a governess and her failed career as a school proprietress, and allowed her to become a professional writer.

A Vindication of the Rights of Woman is by far her most famous work.   Despite its title, it's not really a general justification of rights for women. It's a treatise on education, and in particular, women's education.   Its title is a product of its time, and a product of marketing. Wollestonecraft was writing in the immediate aftermath of the French revolution of 1789, and its Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen.  More particularly, her title echoes that of her own earlier work, A Vindication of the Rights of Man, which was written as a hot rebuttal of the conservative Edmund Burke's Reflections on the Revolution in France.  That book made her reputation and gave her a public profile.  It was natural to title her next book in such a way as to remind readers of that fact.

Is the book relevant today?  I bookmarked a few quotes that could have been written yesterday.  But overall, its arguments aren't ones that one would make today, at least in the Western world.  In Vindication, Wollestonecraft argues that women's intellectual and moral inferiority is a result of their ignorance.  When girls were educated at all, their education focused on domestic skills and pleasing men.  The result:  ignorant, petty, and vain women who were unfit for their natural roles as mothers,  teachers of children, and companions to men.  Worst of all, women were unfit to live moral lives.  The cure that Wollestonecraft advocated was to educate girls alongside boys, teaching all children the same range of historical, philosophical, and religious subjects.

Is there any reason to read Vindications today?  It's certainly an important historical work.  If you're interested in Mary Wollestonecraft, it is an essential complement to reading about her life. And like the Claudine novels, Vindications throws unintended light on the era in which it was written.

Wollestonecraft was raised in a family that skimmed the bottom of the middle class through the improvidence of her father.  She worked as a governess for aristocratic Irish families.  She operated a school for middle class girls, and she circulated in intellectual circles both in England and later in Revolutionary France.  She was, of course, acquainted with servants, with whom she lived for most of her life.  The portrait that she paints of women's lives was drawn from her own experience.  It was designed to resonate with her audience as plausible background to her arguments for women's education.

It's upsetting.

The most telling part is that Wollestonecraft didn't argue that women would be just as able as men, given the same education and opportunities.  Either she didn't believe that herself, or she thought that such an argument was be too far beyond the pale to be included in a serious work of analysis and advocacy -- even as she demonstrated her own learning via extensive in-line references to various learned sources throughout her work.  

And even if you're familiar with period literature, you don't get the texture of everyday life from Jane Austen.  Wollestonecraft paints a world where men automatically patronized women or preyed upon them....or both.  Where women were on the whole ignorant, gossipy, scheming, weak, and silly...because middle class and aristocratic women had no outlet for their energies, no cultivation for their minds, and were degraded by the necessity of obedience first to their fathers, and then to their husbands.  Even 'progressive' contemporary thinkers like Rousseau valued women almost exclusively for their appearance.

Yes, Wollestonecraft was writing a polemic.  But from my young experiences working various blue collar jobs, I found that gossip, opinion, and petty scheming are much closer to the surface among people with less education.   Education really does broaden one's perspective -- or at least teaches you to moderate your less attractive instincts.  In a world where women's education was discouraged or blocked, I can well imagine that her world looked much as she described.

The moral of the story: if you're a woman, it's hard not to believe in historical progress.  Female time travellers take note! Visiting different eras would be fascinating, but if you're looking to settle somewhere, the modern era rocks.



Friday, 11 September 2015

The Franchise Affair by Josephine Tey

Pages: 300
Published: 1949

I've read and enjoyed a couple of other books by Josephine Tey:

But not every classic book is worth reading, not even if the author generally amuses. Perhaps it was just my mood, but this book grated. 

I suppose that for a class system to survive, the people who benefit from it need to believe that it's justified.  

The heroines of this piece are a wrongly-accused pair of spinsters: a mother and daughter of good family but limited means.  Their case is taken up by a middle-aged lawyer, who succumbs to the appeal that he should help them, not because of his expertise, but because he's "one of the right sort", that is, of the right class.  The villain comes from a lower class, and is in fact adopted.  Upon investigation, we learn that the villain's mother was of poor character.  It all makes perfect sense: after all, bad blood will out. 

There's more, much more.  Including the interesting fact that you can always tell a murderer, because they inevitably have their eyes set slightly asymmetrically in their sockets.  But I draw a veil over the rest of the book.  I think you get the idea.

The actual mystery is somewhat novel, and is apparently based on an historical event:  it deals with an accusation of kidnapping, and the suspense involved is the attempt of the investigator to clear the afore-mentioned polite spinster and her mother.  The suspense would be greater if there were any suspicion that they weren't -- OF COURSE-- innocent, given their social class.

The only part that made me laugh was the heartfelt question of the struggling spinster, trying to clear her name.  "What do people do who have no money?"  she asks, as she struggles to pay the expenses involved with the investigation.  The question is meant to elicit sympathy. 

But the answer is that they are convicted both by the courts and by public opinion.  No one reaches out to help them, and no one believes them, as the country lawyer believes the spinster.  Those with no money at all are obviously inherently criminal.





Monday, 17 August 2015

Claudine at School by Colette

Started: 12 July
Finished: 25 July
Pages: 187

I first read Colette when took a class in 20th Century French Literature in translation, offered by the French department at the University of Saskatchewan back in the 1980s.  I think that must be why I picked up a second-hand copy of The Claudine Novels at some point, and why I finally pulled it down off the shelf earlier this month when I was looking for something to read.

More or less by coincidence, I also started reading A Vindication of the Rights of Woman by Mary Wollestonecraft and a book of SF short stories by Judith Merrill at almost the same time.  Claudine at School was written in the 1890s, Vindications was written about a hundred years earlier in 1792, while the Judith Merrill short stories were written between the late 1940s and the 1970s. All three are by and about middle class women.

I feel a bit as if I'm starting a "compare and contrast" essay.  But perhaps I'll desist, given that I haven't yet finished Vindications or the Merrill stories, and it's been more than 25 years since I wrote my last literary essay.  I will say that reading the three books together felt a bit like time travel: as I write about the other books perhaps I'll pull a bit of commentary together.

Of the books, Collette's is not self-consciously a commentary on women and women's lives.  This is her first novel, written as a very young married woman, to please a demanding older husband who eventually got the book published under his own name.  Her later novels explore women's lives, but this one simply describes the life of a teenaged girl attending her local village school.

Claudine at School is described as "charming" on Wikipedia and in its introduction.  And so it is.  It's  a slice of a lost time, set in a quiet village where a visit from a local politician is enough to justify an all day program of welcoming songs by schoolchildren dressed in their best clothes and speeches by local dignitaries. It's a time when girls from village families might get an education so that they could train as school teachers, girls from not-so-ambitous families might snatch kisses from boys in the forest, while girls from good families like Claudine might go to school solely to keep themselves amused while waiting for their lives to begin.  The book's not quaint:  the school girls and school teachers leap off the page as real, complicated, squabbling people.  And because the book was originally written as soft porn (Colette's husband kept nagging her to make the contents 'hot'), it reads as surprisingly modern.  (Lesbians, oh my.)

Would I recommend it?  Colette's later books, like The Captive are more interesting.  Claudine feels more like backstory, and a reminder of some of the ways that women's lives have changed (more opportunities), and have not changed (harassing male authority figures) over the last 100 plus years.


Tuesday, 7 July 2015

The signal and the noise: why so many predictions fail -- but some don't by Nate Silver

Started: May 21, 2015
Finished (ish): 4 July 2015
Pages: 457

There is a genre of book that I tend to pick up in airports.  No, not thrillers or romances.  Intellectual books of various kinds that pique my interest by addressing something that's top of mind for me.  Or at least,  they create a top-of-mind subject  by virtue of being right in front of me at a time when I know I'm going to be trapped in a chair for hours in the immediate future...albeit without quite enough oxygen for full mental processing. But still.

I picked this one up as a result of a recent visit to Saskatoon.  The blurb appealed to me, and work and workish books were on my mind, particularly questions about work-related predictions.  I told myself that the book would be interesting, and perhaps even useful.

And it was interesting, if nowhere near as profound as the cover blurb promises. "Could turn out to be one of the more momentous books of the decade."  Um...no.  Everything momentous in this book is more ably and rigourously covered in Thinking: Fast and Slow.   And at least some of the interest of the book comes from factors outside of the direct content of the book itself.  But that doesn't mean that the book was dull or pointless.  Just not profound.

What do I mean by all of that? And what is the book about?

Nate Silver famously made a 100% correct prediction of the results of the 2012 American presidential election, at a time when pundits were calling the election too close to call and pollsters were suffering public angst about the present and future of political polling.  He parlayed that success into this book, which discusses the art and science of prediction by examining its successes and failures in a number of different fields.

What did I learn from the book?   The coolest thing is that for the first time, I feel that I have some understanding of  Bayesian statistics.  Thank you Nate Silver.  I've heard Bayesian statistics discussed in passing many times, without really knowing what was meant.  Silver not only explains what they are, he illustrates how they are used and why they are significant.  It's not like Silver invented Bayes Theorem, but good communications skills matter, and his explanation is a useful contribution.

I also learnt the current state of a number of fields, like weather prediction and earthquake prediction, which is kind of interesting, if not life-changing.

But part of the interest of the book comes out of my 'meta-learning'. Silver talks about himself and his own experiences with prediction throughout the book.  Don't blame Silver: it's a modern non-fiction book style to write about yourself while you write about your subject. But one of the distracting side-effects of this style is that I felt that I was learning about Nate Silver as I read, and what I primarily learnt was that Nate Silver is smart, opportunistic, and ultimately kind of shallow.

No, I'm not sure why that really matters.  But Silver has apparently built his career by learning something about Bayesian reasoning and the kind of decision-making fallacies that we are all prone to (as described in Thinking: Fast and Slow), and then finding fields that are under-serviced in terms of the rigorous application of these principles to prediction.  He's helped develop a program that took a new approach to predicting the performance of baseball players, he made a bunch of money in the great internet poker boom in the mid-2000s, and after that crashed he focused on poll-based political predictions.

So, while the book is interesting, it isn't profound or life-changing, or really applicable to ones' own life circumstances.  A 7 out of 10, maybe?

Thursday, 18 June 2015

Adventures in time and space with Max Merriwell by Pat Murphy

Started: June 12
Finished: June 17
Pages: 287

Do you like your fiction "meta"?  Adventures in time and space with Max Merriwell may take the "meta" cake.  Pat Murphy was so dedicated to telling this story of fiction, reality, fictional reality and quantum possibility that she wrote two other novels under pseudonyms (There and Back Again "by Max Merriwell", and Wild Angel "by Mary Maxwell") to support it!  Or at least she tried:  apparently her publishers insisted that those two books appear under her own name.  But the earlier novels get their "proper" attribution in Adventures, and Murphy gets her revenge: Adventures features two characters named "Pat Murphy",  neither of whom is a self-portrait.

That gives you a flavour of the book, as does the fact that both Max Merriwell and Mary Maxwell both appear as characters, and Susan, a character in Adventures, reads both There and Back Again and Wild Angel during the course of the novel.

Whew.  That was sufficiently self-referential that it was difficult to express clearly.  I'm sure that Murphy had even greater difficulties keeping it all clear in the novel itself.  But she manages:  the book comes across as a romp.

Pat Murphy's day job is as a science writer at the Exploratorium.  She's written a Nebula-award winning novel (Falling Woman), and is also notable as one of founders of the James Tiptree, Jr award for fiction. If this novel is any indication, she is also likely to be a lot of fun at a party.  Or maybe not:  maybe we should imagine her as a dour recluse, to make her as unlike as possible to her fiction.  I suspect she'd enjoy that.


Thursday, 4 June 2015

D.A. by Connie Willis

Started: 1 June 2015
Finished: 1 June 2015
Pages: 76

D.A. is a YA novelette.

It was way too tempting to describe the book this way:  first of all for the acronymitis (too many years in high tech have made me far too susceptible), and for the excuse to use jargon.

For the benefit of those not familiar with SF fiction prize categories, I didn't make up "novelette". Novelettes are works of fiction between 30-70 pages long.  Novellas are their slightly longer siblings, ranging from 70-160 pages.  Technically, D.A. may count as a Young Adult novella rather than a novelette, but I'd have to do a word count to be sure as D.A. does include pictures.

Now that I have that out of the way, what did I make of D.A.?

D.A. tells the story of a teenager who gets accepted into the insanely elite and competitive Space Academy....even though she didn't apply.   "Why would I apply?" she asks.  "I've told you a hundred times that I don't want to go into space.  I want to go to UCLA."

How is it?  I think it would be great for a young teenager /tween who had some interest in science fiction.  It's light, it's fun, and it was written by Connie Willis, who has 11 Hugo awards and 7 Nebula awards proving that she knows how to write.  For an adult, it's a perfectly acceptable brief entertainment.  After all, when's the last time you read a book with pictures?

Monday, 1 June 2015

Stuff Matters by Mark Miodownik

Started: 15 April
Finished: 24 May
Pages: 252

Being interrupted is bad.  This isn't a long book, and it isn't a difficult book.  But for one reason or another my reading of it was interrupted a couple of times.   With a novel, that can mean feeling like I've wandered back into a conversation with strangers.   With a nonfiction book it just means a curiously disrupted perception of the the book's contents.

So, apologies to the book, and its author. It deserved better.

Stuff Matters belongs to the now-venerable tradition of nonfiction works begun by Much Depends on Dinner back in 1986.  The author begins with a simple everyday artefact -- in this case, a photo of himself sitting on a roof patio -- and devotes a chapter to exploring the history, sociology, and science of items within that artefact.  Mark Miodownik is a materials scientist, so his focus is on exploring the materials that make up everyday objects:  things like paper, concrete, chocolate, and china.

Stuff Matters won the 2014 Winton Prize for Science Books. The judges said "This brilliantly written book is a fresh take on material science that makes even the most everyday stuff exciting and interesting. It demonstrates just how creative and ingenious the human mind can be in its ability to incorporate them into our lives.”  Personally,  I think the primary reason Miodownik won, and the primary virtue of the book is how imaginative he is.  Each material he discusses is treated in a different way.  For example, he wrote a film script for the "plastic" chapter.

The only "but" to this book is that if you have a science background, you might find the contents a little bit basic.  Not that the science is less than rigourous--I definitely learned things--but that as a science reader you may have encountered some of the contents before in different contexts.  But hey,  I picked up fun facts that I was able to insert into conversation twice within a couple of weeks.  And the book is entertaining and engaging, and might just get you interested in the science of the "stuff" that surrounds us all.