Wednesday, 21 June 2023

Babel by R. F. Kuang

 I pretty much hated this book, and I am struggling to understand why. 

First of all, why would I expect to love this book?  Well, what's not to love?  

  1. Kuang is an award-winning author, whose books have been best-sellers.  Those factors should mean that her books are both well-written and engaging.  
  2. As far as topics go, Babel takes place in a fictionalized fantasy version of 19th Century Colonial Britain, featuring a hero who is a half-Chinese scholar born in Canton.  It's an interesting setting, with an interesting premise.
  3. Kuang is a first generation American whose parents were born in China. She herself is a scholar of Chinese history and culture.  The book should be told from a highly expert and insightful perspective. 
  4. Babel features an anti-colonialist hero who first joins a secret society designed to undermine British hegemony, and then builds a student-worker coalition as part of a rebellion against colonialism.

All good, right?  

Alas, in practise I stopped reading Kuang's first novel, The Poppy War, half-way through and I had the same impulse half-way through Babel. 

This time pushed to the end, trying to understand what wasn't working for me.

It's not that Kuang is a young academic, and that her books show it.  The protagonists of both the The Poppy War and Babel are brilliant, penniless young students, but the struggle of the heroine of The Poppy War to triumph in the imperial entrance exams kept my attention.  So did the beginnings of the academic journey of the hero of Babel, who is scooped out of China as a young boy, and set to intensive study of Latin and Greek to prepare him for Oxford and his future at the Institute of Translation.  Babel continued to hold my attention as 'Robin Swift' enters Oxford and encounters his first real friend -- fellow student Ramy-- and as together they build their academic careers through their first years of university.

But about half-way through Babel my interest really began to flag.  There were lots of events -- so many events!  So much drama! -- as Swift and his classmates struggle with various challenges at Oxford, year by year, and as Swift encounters his mysterious brother Griffen and the even more mysterious Hermes Society.  

But at some point I stopped caring.  Maybe there were simply too many events?  It felt as if this story could have been several books.  Or perhaps the problem is that Kuang should have pruned this story to create a more satisfying overall story arc.  As it is now there were too many challenges, too many mini-crises and resolutions, with no clear emotional direction for the overall story.

It didn't help that I felt a limited emotional connection with the characters.

Only Robin our hero was fully-drawn.  To a lesser extent Ramy also comes alive on the page.  But we don't see enough of Griffen to understand him, or care about him and his passions.  (When we finally do begin to understand Griffen, it's because Robin tells us about him, not because Kuang shows him to us.) Dr. Lovell is an evil colonialist.  Letty is a caricature, and annoyingly, one whose character and life story don't feel true to 1830s England.   Victoire hardly existed at all until the very last pages of the book.

Then there are the plot problems that start coming thick and fast from the midpoint onwards. Why would Babel overlook what seems to them to be Robin's treachery? Why do they also send the other 4th year students to China alongside Robin, when those student's skills are irrelevant to the project at hand? And how does it happen that four of the most brilliant scholars at Oxford are so beef-witted about covering up a crime? 

And then Kuang suddenly kills off most of the characters to create a crisis point.  

I 'm so old I remember when it was considered edgy to kill off central characters!  But instead of it being a shock that enlivens the story, here killing off central characters feels like a contrivance -- one that makes it hard to feel invested in the story's ultimate outcome.  It doesn't help that our hero claims to be devastated but we don't feel that devastation.  Or that our Hero and his remaining brilliant colleagues (and their revolutionary working class allies) seem so naive about strategy.  

Am I a curmudgeon?  Undoubtedly.  Can I write a book as good as R. F. Kuang's?  Of course not.  Will her writing improve as she matures and gains both more life experience and more writing experience?  I hope so.  Or maybe I am just being far too curmudgeonly in even saying that!  She's writing relevant books that appeal to a best-selling-sized audience, an audience that cares more about her passion, her perspective, and her world-view than the flaws that I see.

Good for her.  May she write many more. I just doubt that I'll read them.

----------------Addendum--------------------------------

I attended the Surrey Writer's Conference this past November, and a comment that Mary Robinette Kowal made there stuck with me.  Roughly "Readers will love your work for what you do well."

Readers love R.F. Kuang for what she does well -- write stories from a uniquely Asian perspective, foregrounding the experience of People of Colour from non-Western cultures.

Babel does this extremely well -- it makes Imperial Victorian England an entirely new place to a Western reader situated in a culture that mostly sees this era through the eyes of contemporary authors like Dickens (where the Empire that makes his society possible is invisible) or modern authors like Neal Stephenson (who use the era to create a romanticized steampunk past). 

Even the annoying ahistorical Lety serves a purpose in this perspective:  she exists to allow Kuang to vividly illustrate the idea of 'white women's tears' and the impact on POC of supposed white allies who don't see their own privilege and whose words and actions centre their own experience instead of supporting those of POC.

I can see and appreciate those values.  I took them too much for granted in my previous review, perhaps because there remains something about how Kuang paces her stories that really doesn't work for me, making me focus on all of the elements of her books that annoy me, instead of all of the things that she does really well.

Monday, 17 April 2023

The Dawn of Everything: A New History of Humanity by David Graeber and David Wengrow

I expected to love this book.  I expected to want to write about it in some detail.  I began enthusiastically,  underlining passages and taking notes as I read.

Spoiler alert:  I did not love this book. It took me a long time to finish, and my notes have been sitting unread for weeks.  I also feel very unmotivated to revisit them and to write this review.

But waste not, want not.  Given that I went to the effort, I might as well share a few thoughts.

To start with, don't get me wrong.  The Dawn of Everything is eye-opening!  It may well change the way you understand human prehistory.  You will certainly learn a lot, even if you already have some interest in prehistory and/or have visited some of the archeological sites referenced in the text.  Not to mention that the authors are frequently amusing.  Graeber and Wengrow bring a sly sense of humour to what is literally 'ancient history'.

My fundamental problem is that the book failed to answer the question it set for itself -- not the question that they began their journey with ("what are the roots of inequality in today's societies?") -- but the question they circle through all 500+ pages of their text "are the kinds of deeply unequal societies we live in today inevitable?"

To be fair, it's a lot to expect an answer to that question and I probably shouldn't have expected one, despite the frequent promises in the text itself.  I might have been overall more satisfied with my reading if I had expected exactly what this book delivers: a re-examination of the evidence we have about human societies throughout history and prehistory, and a thorough debunking of the mythology of "human progress" that we are all familiar with. You know the one: "Humans started as hunter-gatherers, living in an idyllic state of nature in small groups.  Then we invented agriculture and settled down, developing task specialization, cities, and kings and armies along the way."  Or possibly the more Hobbesian view (shared by Stephen Pinker) -- "We developed civilization to protect ourselves from the unending 'war of all against all'".  

As it turns out, neither perspective offers much value as a description of human prehistory. 

As Graeber and Wengrow point out, it's easy to forget that human prehistory is very very very long.  Biologically modern humans have existed for somewhere north of 150,000 years, while our oldest written records date back only about 5000 years.  That means that there is time enough for human prehistory to be far stranger, more complex, and more various than we generally imagine.

For example, the more we learn, the more we discover that prehistory abounds with examples of settled groups of hunter-gatherers (Haida, people of Çatalhöyük),  peoples who adopted agriculture and then abandoned it (notably, the builders of Stonehenge), and even non-hierarchical cities (Teotihuacan does not contain the kinds of images of warrior-kings found in other MesoAmerican ruins, instead featuring vast complexes of apartment buildings that housed peoples of all social classes.  There are ancient large circular settlements in Eastern Europe that seem to be designed that way on the 'Arthur's round table' principle -- in other words, they seem deliberately designed to prevent any subgroup from claiming undue significance or prestige due to their location within the larger group.)

Which brings us to one of the other main points that Graeber and Wengrow are at pains to make: we have no reason to believe that ancient peoples were any less clever than we are, or any less deliberate in making choices about how, where, and with whom they lived.  Just because a people did not have a written language (or a written language that we still have evidence of or that we can still read), does not mean that those people somehow lived 'in a state of nature' dictated by their predetermined stage of 'cultural evolution'.   

So read this book if you're interested in learning more about recent discoveries about human prehistory, and if you're interested in a contrarian view about what those discoveries show and mean.  Also read this book for the many interesting perspectives and asides that the authors provide about human culture and cultural influences.  

One example: Wengrow and Graeber  examine the possibility that North American First Nation's way of life influenced and inspired the European Enlightenment.

After all,  how was it that European thinkers like Rousseau developed their ideas around liberty, equality, individualism, toleration, and rationality in the first place? There was literally no precedent for these ideas in the religiously rigid, hierarchical societies of late medieval Europe.  Could the rise of these ideas have anything to do with the contemporaneous contact that French society had with egalitarian North American cultures like that of the Wendat (Huron) people?  

The Wendat viewed with something between horror and disdain the idea that anyone had the right to compel obedience from another. Instead they chose to govern themselves via councils that featured endless articulate and philosphic debate.   

Sounds like a stretch to think that the Wendat helped to inspire the Enlightenment?  One of the most popular books in early 18th century Europe was a book written by a French priest (Lahontan) who had recently returned from what is now modern Canada.  The book is a scathing critique of French society written in the form of a dialog between Kandiaronk (a notable Wendat) and the priest.  

The book has traditionally been interpreted as being a liberal critique of French society that simply uses a mythical Wendat as an interlocutor.  Perhaps -- but Kandiaronk was a real person.  His existence is documented in First Nation's oral history, and in multiple contemporary European historical accounts.   Moreover, these historical accounts (letters, journals, church reports) are uniformly admiring of Kandiaronk's intellect -- one Jesuit calls him 'surely the most intelligent man who ever lived'.  And remember, Jesuits were the intellectuals of the Catholic Church. 

So why shouldn't we believe that the critiques of European society attributed to Kandiaronk were his own?   Particularly given that Lahontan knew Kandiaronk, and there is a plausible argument to be made that Kandiaronk himself actually visited France as part of an Indigenous delegation that visited the French court in 1691.  So why shouldn't we believe that a book that was widely read and widely translated affected the intellectual climate of its time? 

That argument gives you a taste for the kind of information and analysis that Graeber and Wengrow provide throughout the thoroughly entertaining (and well-referenced) pages of The Dawn of Everything.  Just don't expect their discussions to come to the conclusions that they claim to be pursuing.

Sunday, 19 February 2023

Meditations by Marcus Aurelius

It's absurd to write a critical review of a book that has endured for more than 1500 years.  It's even more absurd to do so without finishing that book, especially given how short it is (163 small pages in the edition I picked up from my closest little free library).

But I just can't.

Meditations is a foundational work of Stoicism, written by the Roman Emperor and philosopher Marcus Aurelius in the second century AD.  The very fact that this text still exists after all this time is a testament to the wisdom that generations of readers have found in its words. 

But when Aurelius writes of accepting whatever life gives you with a quiet mind because it is what Nature has allotted to you, I can't help reflecting how much easier it would have been to do so as the adopted son of an emperor, and then emperor yourself than it would have been to do so as one of his own slaves. When Aurelius rates the "womanish" sins of desire (sins that are pleasurable) as worse than the (more manly) sins of passion (involuntary loss of control), I reflect first on the misogyny of calling such sins feminine, and then on how sins of desire primarily hurt the sinner while sins of passion like 'striking out in anger' hurt others.   And then there's the irony of the passages that speak of the futility of seeking lasting fame.  :-)  

This isn't a book that speaks to me, even if I could learn from the Meditations on procrastination, keeping an even keel, and the other lessons that I haven't yet read (and probably never will).

Sunday, 11 September 2022

From Left to Right: Saskatchewan's Political and Economic Transformation by Dale Eisler

What happened to Saskatchewan?  I grew up in a province that was home to the NDP, the cooperative movement, the Wheat Pool, and Medicare. Last year my sister said to me, off-handedly, "Saskatchewan is a right wing province".  It startled me, but she's right: the NDP has lost every federal seat that they once held, and the right-wing Saskatchewan Party has a stranglehold on provincial power.  Voters don't care about serious financial and political scandals (Global Transportation Hub), or huge financial deficits (Grant Devine conservatives, current Saskatchewan Party), as long as the perpetrators are self-proclaimed conservatives. In 2021 pandemic policy became "Whatever Jason Kenney says".  The resulting wave of deaths and the near-collapse of the province's health care system reduced the current premier's popularity, but hasn't brought any real political consequences.

What the f* Saskatchewan?

When I saw this book I grabbed it, hoping for answers.  

Sigh. 

I didn't want the answer to be "It's because people are stupid and easily led."

To be clear, that's my conclusion, not Eisler's.  Eisler blames the NDP itself, after outlining political events in Saskatchewan in some detail from the 1970s through the 2000s.  But while the NDP certainly had "fails" (that coalition with the Liberals in 1999 certainly looks daft for both the Liberals and NDP in retrospect), nothing the NDP did or didn't do explains a few mysteries.  

Why don't the Saskatchewan people care if conservative governments run deficits?  In the 1980s, Grant Devine took Saskatchewan from a surplus to the largest per-capita deficit in the country. Today's Saskatchewan Party has won 4 majority governments in a row while consistently running deficits -- mostly during an era of high commodity prices that should have made running surpluses a piece of cake.

Why don't the Saskatchewan people value competent government?  The Romanow government of the 1990s made some hard choices to eliminate the Conservative deficit. But apparently those choices completely destroyed the credibility of the NDP in rural Saskatchewan, despite farmers' supposedly hard-headed pro-business perspective on economic issues, and despite the depopulation of rural communities which made those policies rational. Why didn't the Calvert government of the 2000s get credit for the economic growth that they created?  Why does the credit instead go to Brad Wall, who simply continued or doubled-down on NDP economic policies?

Eisler's answer would be that politics in Saskatchewan is essentially populist.  Saskatchewanians feel like outsiders in the Canadian federation. They feel that their political and economic interests are subsumed to those of Ontario and Quebec, which gives them a sense of grievance that is core to Saskatchewan identity.  Tommy Douglas was successful because of his charisma, and because he understood that sense of grievance and offered a collectivist solution: in Saskatchewan we work together to build a better life in spite of indifferent Easterners and rapacious capitalists. Grant Devine was successful and defeated the fiscally competent Blakeney government (that was focused on the fate of rural communities, no less) because he spoke to people's immediate concerns about affordability (concerns derived from factors that were entirely outside the control of the provincial government).  Brad Wall defeated the competent, growth-focused Calvert government because he was charismatic and projected a vision that Saskatchewan could be "more".

In other words, people vote based on emotion, not based on facts.  Or, as I prefer to put it, people are stupid and easily led.  

Yes, I understand that phrasing the issue in this way means that I don't have a future in politics.  But I want politics to be about issues.  I want the art of politics to be about figuring out how to implement rational, intelligent policies in a competent way, and political difference to be about differences of opinion about priorities and the relative importance of certain shared values.  

Apparently that makes me either an alien or naive. 

Eisler certainly belongs to the camp that sees gaining political power as the sole point of politics, and  policy simply as a tool to keep that power.  I mean, he's not alone: the entire existence of the Liberal Party of Canada is based on those principles, and no political party is without adherents to that philosophy (looking at you Bill Tieleman).  But because Eisler doesn't doesn't see politics as being fundamentally about values, he doesn't really address the question of values in his book.  And I think that's a real gap.   

So I still don't know WTF happened to the province of my birth. Other than to believe that Saskatchewanians are stupid and easily led -- which, given that 40% of them don't believe that climate change is real, might actually be the answer. <tears>

Tuesday, 16 August 2022

Everyone knows your mother is a witch by Rivka Galchen

This book has a great title.  Who wouldn't pick it up off the shelf? The title also really captures the voice of the protagonist and the tone of the writing.  It's thematically appropriate too.  If there isn't a book award for titles*, there should be, and Everyone knows should be nominated.

Title aside, Everyone knows your mother is a witch has a lot to recommend it. First of all, it's short.  Yeah for short books, and especially for short historical fiction!  There's a time and a place for wrist-busting world-building, but Everyone knows shows that you don't need to include pages of historical background, detailed descriptions of places, people, and things, or write in an accurate historical dialect to capture something essential about a time and a place and a person.  Instead, Everyone uses the voices of the accused witch (Katharina), her neighbour Simon, and the depositions of Katharina's accusers to build a compelling picture of an aged widow whose sharp eyes, sharper tongue, and complete lack of tact turn much of her community against her.

So read about Katharina Kepler, the illiterate mother of Imperial Mathematician (and famed physicist) Johannes Kepler, laugh at her observations of the ducal governor Einhorn (the false unicorn), smile at her fondness for her cow Chamomile, and ponder the fate of this "frighteningly intelligent woman -- also a fool". 

You won't regret it.


(*The Diagram Prize is awarded to the book with the oddest title, which is not at all the same.)


Wednesday, 27 July 2022

21 Things You May Not Know About the Indian Act by Robert P. C. Joseph

I wasn't sure I needed to read this book. While I'm not a student of Canadian history, I was pretty sure that I was already familiar with at least some of the most egregious parts of the Indian Act: things like residential schools, the pass system that confined Indigenous peoples to reservations unless they had written permission to leave, legal provisions that stripped "Indian" status from women who married non-Indigenous men, suppression of vital cultural practices like the Potlatch and the Sun Dance, and the paternalistic administration of reservation lands. In short, maybe "I knew this stuff" and there might be better books for me to read about the experiences of First Nations peoples in Canada?

But you don't know what you don't know. I decided to read it anyway.  

I did learn some important things. For example, context. In the 18th Century and before, "Canadian" governments saw First Nations....as Nations.  For all their inadequacies, treaties were genuinely viewed as treaties in the same sense as international treaties are today.  The Indian Act crystallized a changed understanding.  In the eyes of the Canadian government,"Indians" became wards of the state, dependents, problems to be managed, and peoples to be assimilated.  

More context: despite the fact that Act-imposed "Band Councils" are democratically elected,  their powers are limited in scope, prescribed by the federal government, and emasculated by having extremely short terms of office -- one or two years -- limiting Councils' ability to plan and act.  

And yet more bitter history:  forced "enfranchisement" stripped "Indian" status from any First Nations person who had the temerity to pursue a legal career or become a clergyman....in other words, the Indian Act declared that anyone who attempted to gain a position of power or respect within white society ceased to be an Indian. 

Yeah.  Sit with that for a minute before moving on.

There is a lot more to digest, of course, in the pages of this book. But overall, 21 Things is a "beginner book" on Canadian - First Nations history, and it only offers a brief introduction to the issues it discusses. For example, Harold Johnson's book has a different understanding of the history of prohibition of alcohol on reserves, and a different perspective on alcohol and its place in White and First Nations communities.   21 Things will not inform you about these differences, or offer insights into the complexities of this or any other issue.  That's not what this book has set out to do.  

Instead, the goal of 21 Things is to open eyes, raise issues, and challenge assumptions by giving an overview of the impact of the Indian Act on First Nations, Metis, and Inuit communities who live within the borders of what is now Canada. Most of us settlers will learn something by reading it.  Most of us should probably go on to learn more after we do.

Sunday, 17 April 2022

Capital and Ideology by Thomas Piketty

 Pages: 1041  (including inline footnotes, excluding index)

Piketty became an international intellectual super-star back in 2014 after releasing Capital in the 21st Century.  Capital and Ideology (published in English in February 2020) is his followup book, intended to answer the question "What now? Can we do something about wealth inequality?"

I can summarize Piketty's answer fairly briefly.

There is nothing natural or inevitable about the level of income or wealth inequality that currently exists.  In fact, inequality was much lower across a broad range of societies in the period 1950-1980 AND economic growth was higher.  

There are proven policies that we could use to radically reduce inequality like steeply progressive income taxes, inheritance taxes, and wealth taxes. Coupled with transnational treaties and transnational governance designed to eliminate tax competition between nations, we could radically and quickly reduce inequality. It is desirable that we do so for reasons of innate economic justice, to build funding and support for critical initiatives like combatting climate change, and because extreme inequality is fostering zenophobia and division.

But Piketty is not brief.  In fact, Capital and Ideology is 1041 pages long. What's worse is that you could get the gist of his argument if you read the 47 pages of the introduction and the 75 pages of Chapter 17: Elements of a participatory socialism for the 21st Century.  

So why is Capital and Ideology so long?  

  • Piketty (or his translator) is wordy: several times I found myself taking a pencil and editing an entire long paragraph down to a sentence. 
  • The book is repetitious.  Given how long it is, the repetition can be helpful.  On the other hand, if the book were shorter it might not be as necessary.
  • Piketty took both the praise and the critiques of Capital in the 21st Century a bit too seriously: 
    • The quotations from Austen and Balzac in that book really enlivened his descriptions of the economies of 19th Century Britain and France. His attempts to find relevant literature to quote when describing the economies of every nation and every time period included in this book just seems laboured. 
    • Piketty was obviously critiqued for focusing too much on Western economies in Capital in the 21st Century, and he makes a real effort to discuss a wider range of nations in Capital and Ideology. Unfortunately, data for many of these countries is not as complete, which makes his efforts to be more inclusive sometime feel more like a 'tickbox' exercise than a true broadening of the discussion.
More importantly, obviously Piketty backs up each point that he makes with copious data and examples, and all of that takes words (and pages).

Should you read this book? Well, Piketty has much more to say my summary does, and some of his stories are fascinating: did you realize that the 19th Century Sweden was the most highly unequal country in Europe? Or that the ruinous and unsustainable level of reparations imposed on Germany after WWI amounted to approximately the same percentage of national income as the debt imposed on Haiti after their 18th Century slave revolt? (Haiti's debt was intended to reimburse slave owners for their losses. Haiti repaid that debt in full over the following 125 years.  Sickening, no?)  Or that France made an attempt to create a transnational governing body for it and its colonies as they gained  independence? (The attempt failed because France refused to share real power.) Or that the American Civil War cost about 1/3 of what it would have cost to compensate slave owners for the economic "loss" of freeing their enslaved workers? (and that no one seriously considered compensating the freed workers for the loss of the value of their years of labour, let alone the trauma of their enslavement?)

These stories are interesting, and sometimes enlightening.  Not to mention that none of what I've said so far even mentions Piketty's analysis of changes in voting patterns since the 1960s (Chapters 14-16) and the rise of 'nativism' in many countries (think Le Pen, Orban, Trump....).  These chapters are thought-provoking and could warrant an entire post of their own.

But sometimes a book makes an impact because it appears at just the right time to illuminate the world around it, and sometimes a book fails to make an impact because its timing is 100% wrong. 

I suspect that Capital and Ideology falls into this latter category.

Reading this book in 2022 reminded me how different the world feels today than it did in 2019, post-pandemic, post-Floyd George, post-Ukraine invasion, and as the climate crisis accelerates.  

If you want to learn more about Capital and Ideology, you can check out some of the professional reviews of the book, like this one from The Guardian.  You can also check out some of the notes I made after finishing it.